Season 5
12 episodes · premiered Jul 15, 2025
It’s time to shake things up.
-
E1 Who Got Yelled at by a Real Housewife?
Izzy, Emily, Danielle, and Siobhan drink algonquins and team up against each other.
-
E2 Who Hooked Up with Someone They Met on the Plane?
Team StarKid members Jon, Lauren, James, and Mariah drink coconut espresso martinis and rate their theater kid energy.
-
E3 Who Got Sued by McDonald’s?
Maame-Yaa Aforo, Hannah Pilkes, Caitlin Reilly, & Corin Wells drink Grant’s Peach and cause some drama.
-
E4 Who Stole Fire Extinguishers From a Hotel?
Paul, Aparna, Kulap, and Reggie drink grasshoppers and try not to be suspicious.
-
E5 Who Got Detained in a Foreign Country?
2nd Try members Zach, Kwesi, Ash, and Keith drink gimlets and share too much.
-
E6 Who Got Walked In on with Their Hair on Fire?
Jiavani, Alex, Matt, and Jacob drink boulevardiers and strike a pose.
-
E7 Whose Mom Outshined Them at a Dance Party?
Roz, Dulcé, Vinny, and Rachel drink Blue Lagoons and pucker up.
-
E8 Who Passed Out at a Movie Theater?
Ryan, Steven, Shane, and Selorm from Watcher drink Three Dots and a Dash and talk like cavemen.
-
E9 Who Won a Stand-Off with a Popstar?
Raph, Chris, Carolyn, and Alexis drink hot buttered rum and give off big leader energy.
-
E10 Whose Mom Was an Accomplice to Armed Robbery?
Zach, Rachel, Jared, and Elyse drink M&Ms and try not to get canceled.
-
E11 Who Ended a Relationship Using Sorcery?
CollegeHumor alums Hayley, Pat, Brian, and Nick drink Lake Erie slushes and learn some new things.
-
E12 Who Joined an Ex on Their Honeymoon?
The cast of Critical Role drinks a Jack Rose and gives Grant a special gift.